Jay

Jay placed fourth on Survivor: New York City. He started out on the Bronx tribe before being swapped to the Brooklyn tribe. Jay was originally placed on the Bronx tribe before being swapped to the Brooklyn tribe. In the sixth cycle of the game, he was sent to Exile Island.

In the eighth cycle, Jay tied for first place in the Memory Video immunity challenge, but lost to Chris C, who completed his quiz in a shorter amount of time.

At the final five, Chris C played an idol on Jay, negating the one vote cast against him.

At final four, Nico tried to make a move against Steph by trying to persuade Jay to vote for Steph, face her in a fire making challenge, and go to final two together. Unfortunately, Jay trusted Steph more than Nico. Franco and Steph, contrary to what they told Jay, voted for Jay and not Nico and Jay was sent home in a 2-1-1 vote.

Jay voted for Nico to win the game.